ListingsAboutAreasJournalWork With Jennifer
For Sale1 / 21

5 bd · 5 ba · 3,866 sqft

$3,985,000

5373 PAU A LAKA ST, KOLOA, HI 96756Koloa, HI 96756

Est. $19,364/moFor Sale · 171 days on market · MLS# 730706

Overview

Bedrooms5
Bathrooms5
Living area3,866 sqft
Price / sqft$1,031/sqft
Home typeHouse
Year built1990
On market171 days
HOA$250/mo

This Kiahuna Golf Village home comes with a second. The detached guest house gives visiting family and friends their own door and their own space. Close enough to share dinner, separate enough to keep their own hours. The 4-bedroom 4-bathroom main home has room to roam, abundant natural light and a casual vibe. Designed by Kauai architect Ginny Latham, the home showcases Andersen windows and doors, along with stucco exterior walls and privacy walls. The gated backyard features an in-ground pool and covered patio designed for easy indoor-outdoor living and entertaining. This property is located within Poipu's Visitor Destination Area (VDA) where vacation renting is permitted. Offered furnished, it is also move-in ready for those looking to call Kauai's South Shore their home. Kiahuna Golf Village is a well-regarded community known for its peaceful setting and convenient access to Poipu beaches, restaurants, shops and recreation. FEATURES Main Home: 3,452 SF Guest House: 414 SF 3-Car Garage: 562 SF Amenities: In-ground Pool

Open houses

  • Sat, Nov 21, 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM
  • Fri, Nov 27, 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM
  • Sat, Nov 28, 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM

AI insights

✦ Property conditionReady to move inBuilt in 1990
✦ Top attributeStrategic Location Advantage
Read the full report
Strategic Location Advantage

This property's location within the Poipu Visitor Destination Area (VDA) and its proximity to renowned beaches, restaurants, and recreational activities create a unique value proposition for buyers seeking a lucrative vacation rental opportunity or a desirable primary residence with strong resale potential

Hidden Potential for Diversified Income Streams

The separate guest house with its own entry and the property's existing success as a vacation rental suggest a compelling opportunity for buyers to explore diversified income streams, such as renting out the main house and guest house separately or leveraging the property's appeal to attract high-paying corporate retreats and events

✦ Price vs. city average$21/sqft above city average
✦ Cost of ownershipHigh cost

The property's large size, premium materials such as Andersen windows and stucco exterior, and high-end features like an in-ground swimming pool and private guest house contribute to its high ownership costs, while its location in a desirable area like Kiahuna Golf Village and its potential for continued use as a vacation rental may also drive up expenses like insurance and maintenance.

Cost & risk

$19,364per month, estimated
  • Principal & interest$19,114
  • HOA$250
  • Down payment (20%)$797,000
Adjust down payment, rate and term

Excludes property tax and insurance. An estimate, not a loan offer.

Climate insurance risk i
Medium

Features

Interior & amenities

✦ Grade B

The property's construction features, such as Andersen windows and doors, stucco exterior, and in-ground swimming pool, meet market standards and provide moderate value creation, although the age of the property and undetermined roof condition may slightly detract from its overall quality.

Interior
High Ceilings
Appliances
Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Gas Cooktop, Microwave, Oven, Washer
Pool
Gunite, In Ground
View
Mountain(s)
Lot
Corner Lot

Structure & style

✦ Grade A

The property's classic design by renowned Kauai architect Ginny Latham, combined with its open floor plan, abundance of natural light, and high ceilings, creates a unique and exceptional value proposition that significantly exceeds market norms.

Levels
Two
Full baths
5
Garage spaces
3
Parking
Attached
Fencing
Masonry
Zoning
R-4

Utilities & HOA

✦ Grade A

The property's utility efficiency is exceptional, with features like zoned heating and air conditioning, and a high utility efficiency rating, which creates significant value for investors or buyers, especially considering the property's popularity as a vacation rental.

Utilities modernity i
B
Utilities completeness i
B
Utilities efficiency i
A
Cooling
Air Conditioning, Zoned
Heating
Zoned
Water
Public
HOA fee
$250/mo
Listing provided by Lori Decker (DRE# RS-76459), Hawaii Life. MLS# 730706, Hawaii Information Service. Listed 2026-06-03.